The Pros and Cons of Shingle Roofing vs. Other Materials

Are you looking to invest in a new roof? If so, it is essential to take the time to learn more about shingles so that you choose the one that is most compatible with your home. There are three primary types of shingles in the market, which are asphalt, metal, and cedar. These roof shingle tiles have their pros and cons, but you should always consider quality, affordability, maintenance and appearance before deciding on which one is right for your home.

Asphalt Shingles

Here are the positive and negative aspects of asphalt shingles:

Pros

Considered to be the most affordable type of shingle among homeowners
Asphalt shingles are lightweight and fire-resistant
Asphalt shingles hold up well to all types of weather
These shingles have a class A fire rating.
DuraGrip adhesive stands up well to high winds
These shingles come with a prolonged life warranty between 25 and 50 years; you also have access to protectant to extend these shingles’ life expectancy
Available in four design styles: Royal Sovereign 3-Tab Shingles, Slateline Designer Shingles, Timberline Lifetime Shingles and Timberline Reflector Series
All American Roofing shingles have algae protection
Available in a wide array of colors including charcoal, hickory and stone gray
Asphalt shingles are energy-efficient and environmentally friendly, meaning that you can also reduce your carbon footprint with a new asphalt roof
This material is low maintenance and easy to repair or replace
Installation is not as complex as other materials

Cons

Asphalt shingles are not the best option for flat roofs.

Metal Shingles

Here are the positive and negative aspects of metal shingles:

Pros

Metal is better on flat or sharply angled roofs
Durable material that can last more than 50 years
Energy-efficient as metal reflects heat and cools your home
Metal material is fire-resistant
Metal is a recyclable material and is environmentally friendly

Cons

Depending on your view, metal roofs during rainstorms may be a bit noisy, although the sound can also be relaxing, so this comes down to personal choice
Metal material and installation are much more expensive than asphalt shingles
They are weighted, which is why most residential homes opt for asphalt
They are hard to repair and replace

Cedar Shingles

Here are the positive and negative aspects of cedar shingles:

Pros

Cedar is aesthetically pleasing on homes
It is lighter than other shingle materials
Wood-based products insulate the home well
Cedar shingles are energy-efficient — more so than any other shingle material

Cons

? It is not as durable or long-lasting as asphalt materials

? Cutting cedar trees for shingles is not environmentally friendly

? They are one of the most expensive materials when you add in installation expenses

? You cannot replace cedar shingles yourself as it is a complex and lengthy process

? It is more difficult to maintain than other materials

? Unlike asphalt tiles, cedar is flammable, which puts your home at risk

If you would like more information or would like to schedule a consultation, please call us on 1300 593 408. You may also contact us here if you would like to receive a free quote.